Subscribe to our newsletter.

PROFESSION

$300k greyhound operation stifles taxpayers’ land tax exemption pursuit


Carlos Tse

By Carlos Tse

16 November 2026 • 4 minute read


300k greyhound operation stifles taxpayers land tax exemption pursuit
Two taxpayers have fumbled their land tax exemption claim after it failed to prove primary production through a cattle grazing agreement of $10 a month, when the NCAT found nearly $300,000 was made by a greyhound training operation on the same property.

The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal has scrapped taxpayers’ attempt to get a land tax exemption after it found that the taxpayers had made the most use of a NSW primary production property for greyhound training despite claiming it was used for cattle grazing and raising cattle.

Leanne and Richard Mifsud acquired the 14.77 hectares of land in NSW in 2017 and put it for lease to a greyhound trainer and a grazier.

“The residence was subject to a lease which commenced on 1 December 2017 which was made [with the trainer]. The rent was $2,000 per week, and $104,000 was paid for the 2025 land tax year,” the tribunal said.

 
 

Mrs and Mr Mifsud applied for an objection against the chief commissioner of state revenue’s land tax assessment in 2025 on the grounds that the property was used for primary production purposes, which failed.

Cattle station or greyhound training grounds

On the property, zoned for primary production, was a residence which was rented out to greyhound racers, a number of unusable dog kennels, an old greyhound track, and runs, and pastures.

Cattle were maintained on the property by the graziers under a grazing lease agreement on 1 June 2024 which was for the sole purpose of grazing cattle for $10 a month, remaining in place on and after 31 December 2024 which at the time had 13 cattle, and they had been placed on the land since June 2024.

In evidence from the chief commissioner of state revenue, about 35 per cent of the land was usable for grazing and about 34 per cent of the land was used for “mixed use” including keeping and training greyhounds.

While the court accepted that only 35 per cent of the land was used for grazing, it said that 85 per cent was used for cattle roaming. Further, it heard evidence that the pastures consisted of a mixture of native grasses, weeds, shrubs and bare soil, all of which were of “little nutritional value.”

“What follows is that the evidence establishes that most of the land was used for maintaining cattle, even if parts of the land were better suited for grazing than other parts,” the court said.

To qualify for the land tax exemption rules through primary production purposes, the dominant use of the land for the maintenance of animals must be for the purpose of selling them or their natural increase or bodily produce.

Time and money investment

While the tribunal found that there was no evidence of any sales of cattle upon the land having occurred during the 2025 year or previously, it was satisfied that the graziers raised the 13 cattle on the land for the purposes of selling them.

“In circumstances where [the graziers] operated a business of farming and selling cattle and moved cattle between various properties before sale, I am satisfied that the animals were maintained on the relevant land for the purpose of selling them.”

The court found that in 2017, the entire land was permitted to keep greyhounds, but from mid–2024, only about 5-7 per cent of the land was used for these purposes. During this time, the greyhound trainer had about 100 dogs on the land in mid-2024 and fell to about 25-30 a year later.

“There were financial pressures and a reduction in the numbers of greyhounds on the land at that time,” the tribunal said.

Despite the financial pressures, the tribunal found: “The financial returns from keeping greyhounds was $289,168 for the period 1 July 2024 to 1 July 2025. The yearly financial return for the applicants from allowing cattle on the land was $120. $104,000 was earned for the 2025 year from rental of the land including the residence to [the greyhound trainer], also representing a cost to [the greyhound trainer].”

The $289,168 earned by the greyhound racer consisted of prize money from racing greyhounds and received hardship payments from Greyhound Racing NSW.

“It is clear that the amount of the return from the land from the activity of maintaining and training greyhounds well exceeded the returns from maintaining cattle, particularly in the absence of any evidence adduced by the Applicants to show what returns were or could be expected to be gained from actual or future sales of cattle maintained on the land.

“The evidence, in other words, establishes that the returns from greyhounds and the costs of maintaining and training them, well exceeded the returns from and costs of maintaining cattle.”

Further to the financial gains, the tribunal found that the graziers spent two hours per week across the year working with the cattle, compared to about 10-12 hours per day working with the dogs over seven days a week for the greyhound trainers.

Determination

“The significant financial gain earned from the activity of greyhound maintenance and training upon the land, taken together with the significantly greater expenses and deployment of labour for that purpose, in my opinion, carry weight that is greater than the factors relied upon by the Applicants in support of their submission that the dominant use was the maintenance of cattle for sale.

“I find as a consequence that the dominant use of the land during the 2025 land tax year was the maintenance and training of greyhounds, even if there was a reduction in the number of dogs upon the land by mid–2025.”

Thus, the tribunal dismissed the applicant’s review application in pursuit of a land tax exemption on the basis that they did not discharge the onus of proof that the dominant purpose of the land was for the purpose of cattle raising as primary production.

The case citation: Mifsud v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2026] NSWCATAD 342 (6 November 2026).

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accounting Times a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Accounting Times as a preferred news source.

Share this article:

Carlos Tse

Carlos Tse

AUTHOR

Carlos Tse is a graduate journalist writing for Accountants Daily, HR Leader, Lawyers Weekly.

KNOW MORE