Subscribe to our newsletter.

PROFESSION

Accountant’s $200k earnings exceeded unfair dismissal remedy application eligibility criteria


Carlos Tse

By Carlos Tse

19 November 2026 • 2 minute read


accountant s 200k earnings exceeded unfair dismissal remedy application eligibility criteria
An accountant paid nearly $200,000 per annum has failed to win his unfair dismissal application after the Fair Work Commission determined that he was paid too much to be covered under the jurisdiction of the Fair Work Act 2009.

Under section 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009, the Fair Work Commission has disallowed an accountant’s unfair dismissal application, finding that he earned $193,000 per annum, which exceeded the $183,100 per annum ceiling for application eligibility.

Nickolas Giorgio worked as a principal accountant at Medcraft Cooper & Associates until his dismissal in late 2025.

Previously, Giorgio served as a principal accountant at Fitzpatrick Ruschinek Zucker (FRZ Accountants) from late 2023, which was acquired by Medcraft’s major stakeholder accounting practice group, Simple Accounting, one month later.

 
 

While working with FRZ, Giorgio earned $150,000 per annum, and this agreement was “transferred” when he went on to work for Medcraft as principal accountant.

Around mid-2024, the directors of Simple Accounting determined that Medcraft had too many staff for the size of the business, and its payroll expenses affected its cash flow. The directors instructed Giorgio to make two staff redundant; a request to which he pushed back.

The two parties reached an agreement that the staff would stay, but Giorgio would begin receiving $110,000 per annum until the business’s cash flow improved.

He earned this reduced amount between 1 September 2024 and 1 July 2025.

Giorgio submitted that he had made an agreement with Medcraft that the wages lost as a result of this wage dock would be recouped later on.

The commission accepted that Medcraft agreed to this “recoup” arrangement.

At the end of the reduced wage period, Giorgio’s wage was bumped up to $193,300.

“In the relevant circumstances, I am prepared to accept on the balance of probabilities that from 1 July 2025, the payment to the applicant of a weekly salary amount calculated at $193,300 per annum was in accordance with an agreement made between the applicant and the respondent for the applicant to be paid that sum in reference to his 2024 to 30 June 2025,” the commission said.

“I find that as at March 2025, [Simple Accounting’s directors] had relative confidence in the cash flow of the respondent, were therefore prepared to agree, and did agree, that applicant would be paid the sum equivalent to $193,300 per annum for a 43-week period from 1 July 2025, which incorporated an amount for the reduced salary component between 1 September 2024 [and] 30 June 2025.”

Giorgio’s unfair dismissal application was at risk of being invalid if the commission determined that he earned $193,300 per annum as at his dismissal.

Giorgio claimed his salary was in fact less than $193,000 as this included the reduced salary component, which was recouped losses, and instead amounted to $150,000 before the addition of the recouped losses, as the “reduced salary component should not be included in assessing the applicant’s annual rate of earnings at the time of his dismissal”.

The $193,000 per annum salary was calculated at a weekly payment of $3,717.31, the commission found.

The commission rejected Giorgio’s assertions.

“I do not consider that any part of the weekly payment of $3,717.31 made after 1 July 2025 and at the time of the applicant’s dismissal, constitutes a “reimbursement”. Therefore, there is no cause to exclude any part of the $3,717.31 weekly payment for the purposes of calculating the applicant’s annual rate of earnings,” the commission said.

Upon consideration of all evidence, the commission determined that Giorgio’s annual salary at the time of his dismissal was $193,300, which exceeded the $183,100 high-income threshold, deeming him ineligible to apply for an unfair dismissal remedy – thus, rejecting his application.

The case citation: Mr Nickolas Giorgio v Medcraft Cooper & Associates Pty Ltd (U2025/15786).

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accounting Times a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Accounting Times as a preferred news source.

Share this article:

Carlos Tse

Carlos Tse

AUTHOR

Carlos Tse is a graduate journalist writing for Accountants Daily, HR Leader, Lawyers Weekly.

KNOW MORE