Doubling large company reporting threshold lacks evidence
23 November 2026 • 4 minute read
National Audits Group managing director Steven Watson has welcomed moves to slash unnecessary reporting audit costs and is not arguing to keep every existing audit.
However, he has insisted that Treasury should publish the evidence for where the line sits before the proposals are legislated.
“I’m not opposed to the proposal in principle and it may well be the right answer. Some companies prefer to keep their information as private as possible from a competition point of view. But nobody is showing us that it is the right proposal,” Watson told Accounting Times.
As part of its FY2026–27 federal budget reform agenda, the federal government announced plans to increase the threshold for ascertaining if a proprietary company is large or small. Treasury released draft regulations in October proposing to increase the thresholds (revenue and gross assets) used in the large proprietary tests.
Treasury’s draft regulations would double the revenue and asset thresholds from $50 million to $100 million and the gross asset thresholds from $25 million to $50 million on or after 1 July 2027.
This would decrease the number of small proprietary companies required to prepare annual financial reports, directors’ reports and sustainability reports. There is no change in the number of employees at 100.
Consultation for the proposals opened on 19 October 2026 and closed on 2 November 2026.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers said these changes will save businesses over $210 million in compliance costs each year, and the reforms would reduce regulatory burden on business by making company reporting better targeted and more effective.
“They’ve thrown out some figures around key savings but there is no evidence or analysis around that either which shows the prices of the audit and what that’s going to save,” Watson said.
Watson said the government doubled the thresholds in 2019, but that included an explanation and evidence. However, in the current instance, he said doubling the threshold is “fairly arbitrary”.
“They’ve doubled it instead of putting any clear science behind it,” he said.
“It was also estimated in 2019 that about a third of the current lodging proprietary companies would drop out, but this time we don’t even know how many entities this would potentially impact.
“The government has got the data. ASIC has got all of the lodged financial statements. They should be able to analyse the impact. We ask that they share a bit more of that analysis. This is not an argument to keep every audit. It’s an argument for showing how they worked out the numbers.”
Watson also pointed out that while smaller suppliers can currently request a copy of lodged accounts of larger companies from ASIC, they would be unable to do this for companies that fall below the proposed thresholds.
“That source essentially disappears for those small suppliers,” he said.
Smaller suppliers could either provide credit with less information while carrying more of the bad debt risk in the economy, or they could protect themselves with shorter terms, deposits, or personal guarantees, Watson explained.
“Either way, we think the small business bears the brunt of the cost and risk,” Watson said.
“When a midsize customer fails, unpaid suppliers could go down with it. We're seeing a lot of that across the construction industry, particularly subcontractors to those construction companies or the large construction companies.”
Watson said he has asked Treasury to publish who is impacted and which companies would stop lodging under the current, proposed, and credible intermediate settings, and who relies on their accounts.
Treasury and ASIC could use better data matching and carefully governed AI to help map company groups and test scenarios, with human reviews and clear privacy controls, he said.
Next, he wants Treasury to explain the numbers, arguing that there is no analysis showing prices, activity, or compliance costs have doubled since the last time thresholds were doubled in 2019.
Thirdly, he has proposed that Treasury count net benefit rather than gross savings as some audits continue under loan agreements, and some costs shift to suppliers and minority owners.
Watson has also asked that Treasury issue worked guidance well before 1 July 2027, when the changes would come into effect and review the results after three years.
In addition, he suggested splitting out some key costs including the preparation of the financial statements, the audit itself, analysis of audit fees for particular companies and where that sits within the threshold, and assessing the effect on sustainability reporting separately.
With the proposed new thresholds not due to come into effect until 1 July 2027, Watson said there is still time for the government to undertake further consultation with audit companies and collect evidence on the decision-making and extend the implementation to the following year if required.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accounting Times a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Accounting Times as a preferred news source.
Malavika Santhebennur
AUTHOR
Malavika Santhebennur is a journalist on the accounting titles at Momentum Media, Accountants Daily and Accounting Times. She writes news about the accounting industry, regulatory changes, compliance, and the wider accounting landscape. Prior to this, Malavika wrote across several brands in Momentum Media and covered a range of industries, including mortgages, broking, law, real estate, wealth, space, aviation, and defence. Before joining Momentum Media in 2019, Malavika wrote for Money Management and Super Review, with a focus on financial services, wealth, and superannuation.
KNOW MORE