Subscribe to our newsletter.

PROFESSION

Tax for risk assets should be less than property: NAB CEO


Malavika Santhebennur

By Malavika Santhebennur

19 November 2026 • 3 minute read


tax for risk assets should be less than property nab ceo
As debate rages on over the government’s tax reforms, the big bank CEO told a parliamentary hearing that taxes for risk assets should not be as high as those for passive or property assets.

At the House Standing Committee on Economics’ public hearing on the review into Australia’s four major banks, independent MP Allegra Spender asked NAB CEO Andrew Irvine if he believed that the same tax settings should apply to existing housing and business investment.

“Does it make sense to have the same tax settings in those two sectors of the economy, when they’re quite different from a productivity point of view?” Spender asked.

Her question came in the wake of her proposal for a flat 40 per cent capital gains tax (CGT) discount on non-property assets to meet the government’s goal of narrowing the gap between how wages and capital are taxed.

 
 

Irvine responded that he was concerned about changes to CGT outside of property asset classes, a view he said he has held since the taxation changes were announced in the May 2026 federal budget.

He said: “The comments that I made at the time were that I can live with the changes to negative gearing and I can live with the changes to capital gains for property.”

Irvine said he had cautioned against the implications of the changes for the property market because Australia cannot have a collapse in pricing.

“But where I had more concern was the changes to capital gains tax outside of property asset classes,” Irvine said and added that he continued to hold this view.

“If Australia is going to be a more dynamic Australia, I think we need to make sure that risk assets are taxed at lower levels than passive or property assets. I would want someone to be able to come here, start a new business, build a business that’s extremely successful and pay a lower tax outcome than if they invested in property, because they’ve taken risk, and I think that’s entirely appropriate.”

In an Australian Financial Review column, Spender called for the government to “change course”, arguing that Parliamentary Budget Office analysis has suggested that her 40 per cent CGT discount proposal would raise similar revenue.

She said it is more competitive and has the support of businesspeople and economists. She pushed for this instead of passing the innovative business CGT concession (IBCC), which she said is “complex, unfair, and leaves many businesses and investors facing internationally uncompetitive rates”.

The AFR also reported that the Greens said they were interested in exploring Spender’s proposed alternative, which could delay the government’s plans to pass its bills through the Senate by the end of next week and avoid it being delayed until next year.

Greens senator Nick McKim said: “I’ve spoken to Allegra about those proposals. They’re very interesting proposals, and we’re having a look at those now. And we’re very happy if that bill does get sent to an inquiry over the summer; very happy to have the inquiry examine the Spender suggestions along with a range of other matters.”

Under the government’s upcoming changes, from 1 July 2027, the flat 50 per cent CGT discount would be replaced with an inflation-adjusted cost base indexation model for resident individuals, trusts, and partnerships and a 30 per cent minimum tax rate for individuals on certain net capital gains which accrue on or after 1 July 2027.

Get rid of ‘atrocious’ payroll tax

During the hearing, Irvine also called for the abolition of the payroll tax in response to a question about how NAB sees the fundamentals of the Australian economy, what features would help it navigate a difficult environment, and how he would like to see the economy leverage the most out of these features as possible.

“We tax payroll. What on earth are we doing?” Irvine said.

“This has to be the most atrocious, abominable tax. It would be like taxing people to give blood, honestly. What are we doing? Get rid of it.”

Irvine said the tax changes announced in the federal budget have “required adjustment”. He said businesses are absorbing higher input costs while business confidence is now at negative 15 according to NAB’s latest survey, 20 points below the long-run average.

While noting that he has not yet seen business insolvencies rising, Irvine said he has seen stress in NAB’s business lending book.

“The level of stress increases as the size of the business reduces,” Irvine said.

“Small businesses are doing it tougher than medium businesses, and medium businesses are doing it tougher than larger businesses.”

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accounting Times a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Accounting Times as a preferred news source.

Share this article:

Malavika Santhebennur

Malavika Santhebennur

AUTHOR

Malavika Santhebennur is a journalist on the accounting titles at Momentum Media, Accountants Daily and Accounting Times. She writes news about the accounting industry, regulatory changes, compliance, and the wider accounting landscape. Prior to this, Malavika wrote across several brands in Momentum Media and covered a range of industries, including mortgages, broking, law, real estate, wealth, space, aviation, and defence. Before joining Momentum Media in 2019, Malavika wrote for Money Management and Super Review, with a focus on financial services, wealth, and superannuation.

KNOW MORE