Subscribe to our newsletter.

PROFESSION

Taxpayer fails to have $1.7m tax recovery case thrown out


Malavika Santhebennur

By Malavika Santhebennur

17 November 2026 • 3 minute read


taxpayer fails to have 1 7m tax recovery case thrown out
The NSW Supreme Court has ordered that a “protracted and strongly contested” alleged tax debt dispute between a taxpayer and the deputy commissioner of taxation can continue on the proviso that the ATO explains the debt more clearly.

In the case of Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Sibai [2026] NSWSC 1435, taxpayer Adnan Sibai and the deputy commissioner of taxation have been involved in a long-running and contentious dispute about an alleged tax debt owed by Sibai (the defendant).

By amended statement of claim (ASOC), the deputy commissioner is seeking to recover $1,677,241.54 in unpaid tax and other interest charges.

In July 2026, Sibai filed a motion seeking an order that the ASOC be struck out by reason of “argued defects” in the form of that pleading. Sibai argued that the ASOC lacked detail and, as such, asked to strike out the claim.

 
 

The judgment read that the ASOC is “sparse” and consists of only nine paragraphs, two of which recount the deputy commissioner’s entitlement to sue and the amount claimed can, for present purposes, be put to one side.

In the remaining seven paragraphs, the deputy commissioner made several allegations including that a running balance account (RBA) was established by them “in respect of primary tax debts due by the defendant under the provisions”, Sibai allocated the “primary tax debts to the RBA”, and he “allocated to the RBA any payments and other credits”.

It was also alleged that Sibai is “liable” to pay almost $1.7 million to the Commonwealth of Australia pursuant to the TAA in respect of the RBA deficit debt.

In relation to the above pleading, Justice Nicholas Chen said five matters should be noted. First, he said, there is no identification in the ASOC of any of the primary tax debts due (nor how, or when, they arose). Second, there is no identification of what the general interest charge amount is.

“Thirdly, although the plaintiff established an RBA ‘in respect of primary tax debts due by the defendant under the BAS provisions’, to the extent that those BAS provisions are identified in the ASOC, it is in general terms in the “particulars”… ‘… BAS provisions include, generally: the goods and services tax provisions, the PAYG withholding provisions, the PAYG instalment provisions, the fringe benefits tax instalment provisions and the deferred company instalment provisions…’,” the judgment said.

The judge added that it appears that rather than an individual having a specific liability for various tax debts, the RBA is used to record all such liabilities.

Finally, the “RBA deficit debt” is the balance of the RBA in favour of the deputy commissioner, based upon liability for various tax debts that remain unpaid after their due date, less any payments or credits, the judge said.

Sibai argued that it remains unclear how the deputy commissioner has determined that he is liable for the tax debt, according to the judgment.

“The ASOC pleads no more than that the debt is owing. It omits to set out the tax debt, separate from any interest, and how (that is, pursuant to what “BAS”) the plaintiff’s liability for that debt has arisen,” the judgment read.

The court ordered the ATO to provide particulars of the primary tax debts to Sibai by 4pm on Monday 25 November, including the dates they arose and when they were allocated to the defendant’s RBA by filing and serving a further amended statement of claim containing such particulars.

The court ordered that costs should follow the eventual outcome, and that they be “each party’s costs in the cause”.

Sibai also filed a second motion seeking an order to temporarily stay the proceedings on the ground that there are judicial review proceedings in the Federal Court involving the parties that concern an aspect of their dispute around his unsuccessful application to the deputy commissioner for remission of shortfall and general interest charges. Sibai wanted to await these proceedings challenging refusals to waive interest.

However, the judge said he was “unpersuaded” that the proceedings should be temporarily stayed and dismissed this motion.

He also ordered the deputy commissioner to file and serve any application to transfer the proceedings to the Federal Court of Australia, together with any evidence in support and an outline of submissions limited to no more than four pages by 18 November at 4pm. The written submissions must not contain any footnotes, he added.

Sibai was ordered to pay the ATO’s application costs for the temporary stay motion.

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accounting Times a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Accounting Times as a preferred news source.

Share this article:

Malavika Santhebennur

Malavika Santhebennur

AUTHOR

Malavika Santhebennur is a journalist on the accounting titles at Momentum Media, Accountants Daily and Accounting Times. She writes news about the accounting industry, regulatory changes, compliance, and the wider accounting landscape. Prior to this, Malavika wrote across several brands in Momentum Media and covered a range of industries, including mortgages, broking, law, real estate, wealth, space, aviation, and defence. Before joining Momentum Media in 2019, Malavika wrote for Money Management and Super Review, with a focus on financial services, wealth, and superannuation.

KNOW MORE