Tax professionals ask if payroll tax is still ‘fit for purpose’
20 November 2026 • 3 minute read
At the House Standing Committee on Economics’ public hearing on the review into Australia’s four major banks, NAB CEO Andrew Irvine said payroll tax should be scrapped in response to questions about how the Australian economy could leverage the features available to it to grow.
Irvine said: “We tax payroll. What on earth are we doing? This has to be the most atrocious, abominable tax. It would be like taxing people to give blood, honestly. What are we doing? Get rid of it.”
Reacting to his fervent suggestion, RSM Australia partner and global employer services leader Rick Kimberley said Irvine’s comments are not inconsistent with other views shared by the broader business community and raise a legitimate question about whether Australia’s payroll tax system “remains fit for purpose”.
“When we look at the history of payroll tax, it was first introduced by the Commonwealth in 1941 during the extraordinary circumstances of the Second World War as a tax on wages associated with funding the new child endowment scheme,” Kimberley told Accounting Times.
“It was subsequently transferred to the States in 1971 and has evolved into an important source of state and territory revenue.”
Kimberley continued that it is a valid policy question about whether taxing employment is consistent with Australia’s objectives of increasing productivity, investment and workforce participation.
“However, the issue is not simply the rate of tax,” he said.
"The payroll tax system has also become increasingly complex, particularly where businesses engage contractors, operate across multiple jurisdictions, or use emerging workforce and platform models.
“At the same time, simply abolishing payroll tax is not straightforward. State and territory governments are heavily reliant upon the revenue and it would need to be replaced from another source or accompanied by lower expenditure.”
There is a significant opportunity for broader tax reform, Kimberley said, adding that questions should be raised around whether a tax conceived in the economic circumstances of 1941, and which has subsequently developed into a highly complex tax on employment and certain contracting arrangements, remains the best way to raise state revenue in 2026.
"In the meantime, national harmonisation, simplification of the contractor rules and more certainty for businesses would be significant reforms in their own right.”
In a similar vein, Pitcher Partners Brisbane partner Anthony Kazamias said the payroll tax system is complex and can create unnecessary competition between states.
He pointed out that there are eight sets of payroll tax rules instead of one, the thresholds are different in each state, and while there is some harmonisation, identical businesses can face different bills depending on which side of a border they are on.
"For businesses operating across borders, those nuances create real compliance costs and uncertainty, diverting resources that could otherwise go towards wages, hiring and investment,” Kazamias told Accountants Daily.
"Governments could deliver genuine productivity gains by pursuing true national consistency in both the legislation and its administration. When an economy begins to falter, you need policy decisions that support investment and encourage productivity."
Council of Small Business Organisations Australia (COSBOA) CEO Skye Cappuccio outlined the industry body’s position on payroll tax and the need for reform, highlighting that payroll tax warrants “serious reconsideration”.
“The fundamental problem is that we are taxing businesses as they employ more people and grow,” Cappuccio told Accounting Times.
“At a time when our focus should be on lifting productivity, growing the economy and creating secure jobs, it makes little sense to have a tax that can act as a disincentive for businesses to hire and expand.”
Cappuccio continued that for small businesses, the burden is not just the tax itself. Indeed, she also highlighted that the different thresholds, rates, and reporting requirements across states and territories create complexity and compliance costs, particularly for businesses operating across jurisdictions.
“COSBOA’s own research found 89 per cent of respondents believed payroll tax should be overhauled because of its impact on jobs and growth. We have consistently described payroll tax as a tax on jobs,” she said.
Echoing the views of others who spoke to Accounting Times, Cappuccio called for a nationally coordinated approach to payroll tax reform, including greater harmonisation of thresholds, rates and reporting requirements, and a broader examination of whether the tax remains fit for purpose in a modern economy.
“If we are serious about supporting small businesses to grow, invest and employ more Australians, payroll tax needs to be part of the reform conversation,” she said.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accounting Times a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Accounting Times as a preferred news source.
Malavika Santhebennur
AUTHOR
Malavika Santhebennur is a journalist on the accounting titles at Momentum Media, Accountants Daily and Accounting Times. She writes news about the accounting industry, regulatory changes, compliance, and the wider accounting landscape. Prior to this, Malavika wrote across several brands in Momentum Media and covered a range of industries, including mortgages, broking, law, real estate, wealth, space, aviation, and defence. Before joining Momentum Media in 2019, Malavika wrote for Money Management and Super Review, with a focus on financial services, wealth, and superannuation.
KNOW MORE